← All guides

Case study: a family of four to Italy on 340,000 Amex points

Ben and his wife were planning a June trip to Italy with their two boys. They had about 430,000 Amex Membership Rewards points and one goal: cover as much of the airfare as possible without overpaying for help.

The challenge. Four seats on the same flights, in June, from North Carolina. Ben wanted reasonable connections with the kids and no wasted day backtracking across Italy. Their first idea was flying into Rome and home from Florence, but the only one-stop flight home from Florence had a 13-hour overnight layover in Frankfurt.

The fix: flip the trip. Instead of fighting the Florence return, we flipped it. Fly into Florence, finish in Rome. That opened up clean one-connection flights both ways on their original dates:

  • North Carolina to Frankfurt to Florence on Lufthansa and Air Dolomiti
  • Rome to Frankfurt to North Carolina on Lufthansa

The numbers. 340,000 Amex points and about $950 in taxes and fees for all four round trips, with roughly 90,000 points left over. The same flights in cash would have cost several thousand dollars.

What it cost them. My fee for the whole family was $275 under my original pricing. Today the same search for four travelers in economy is $375.

How they found me. Ben asked ChatGPT for an award booking service that wasn't free but also wasn't $500 or more for four people. That gap between doing it yourself and paying a big service per person is exactly who this is for.